Financial Symmetry News & Views

Article published on FiLife.com by Financial Symmetry’s Allison Berger, CFP.

Naturally parents want to provide the best for their children. For many parents today this means paying for them to earn a college degree. This is an admirable goal, and one that their children will greatly appreciate when they graduate free from student loan debt. But what does saving for the ever-rising cost of college tuition mean for their other lifestyle goals?

529 plans have become the gold standard of saving for college. They are a great choice because they do not have an annual contribution limit or income threshold. They also allow tax-deferred earnings and tax-free withdrawals for qualified education expenses. While these features are beneficial, 529s also have some negative aspects. The biggest drawback is that the funds must be used for college. Therefore if your child receives a scholarship, decides not to go to college, or you have excess money left over in the 529 after they graduate, your earnings will be subject to federal and state income taxes in addition to a 10% penalty. This emphasizes the importance of not over-funding 529 plans.

While the 10% penalty is enough to discourage over-funding, parents should also consider how they are planning for their own future. Too often retirement planning is put on the back burner until children are off the family payroll. However, student loan options are abundant; retirement savings loans…not so much. Another variable is that parents may have enough income by the time their children go to college that they can pay their expenses out of cash flow.

For these reasons I encourage parents to consider maxing out contributions to their own retirement accounts before funding 529 plans or other education savings accounts. If you are eligible, the Roth IRA is a tool that can work toward both goals. Roth IRAs are funded with after-tax dollars and provide for tax-free withdrawals in retirement. While this is a retirement account, a feature often overlooked is that you can always withdraw your contributions from a Roth IRA tax and penalty free. This makes it a great tool for college planning as well because you can plan to max out contributions every year and withdraw those contributions for use toward college expenses if necessary. In the event you earn enough income that you don’t need to make any withdrawals or your child receives a scholarship, you can leave that money to grow for your own retirement.

The goals and resources of every family are unique. To develop a savings plan most appropriate for your personal situation, seek the guidance of your financial adviser.